Since I’ve been on the road talking about Justice Scalia, I’ve consistently been asked about the fact that six of the nine justices are Roman Catholic and about how that affects the Court’s opinions, particularly those of Scalia. I devoted a chapter to Scalia and religion — Passions of His Mind — and, despite how touchy the intersection of personal belief and judicial views can be, I am ready to field these questions.
From Miami to Milwaukee, one of the most frequently asked questions I’ve fielded in recent weeks relates to how Scalia’s Catholicism influences his rulings. This is a touchy area but clearly one that fascinates people. The question is increasingly asked, too, because there are now six Catholic justices on the Supreme Court. Along with Scalia, they are Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Anthony Kennedy, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Sonia Sotomayor.